Women in AI GTM Award. Nominate someone →

Reference file

Worked examples

worked-examples.md

Field cases

Drawn from real situations. Names, industries, figures, and timelines have been changed or combined to protect the people and companies involved. The first two are a matched pair. The three that follow are shorter supporting cases.

Case 1: Build the bench before the seats become empty

Situation. A global company had a highly experienced, long-tenured senior team. Within 18 to 24 months, more than half of several executive and next-level seats were expected to open through retirement or transition.

The ordinary response. Put two names under every critical box and wait.

What the company did instead. It treated succession as a development system, not a replacement list. It identified high performers and gave them real work across business units and functions: commercial leadership, customer service, finance, operations, risk, legal, people, technology, partner management. It stopped treating commercial and support talent as separate populations, and gave everyone a shared question: how does your work contribute to the outcome the customer and the company are trying to achieve? That common language widened the succession pool and lowered the walls between functions.

One leader showed what the system could produce. Recruited from a competitor, he had moved for exposure, not title. His career ran diagonally across commercial and operational domains. He learned how risk, finance, sales, operations, customers, and partners each thought, and how a decision in one place created consequences in another. Breadth did not make him shallow. It gave him situational fluency: he saw more of the system, judged better, decided faster, and delivered results.

Why he was a real successor, not a popular one. Results made him visible, but four other signals made him ready:

Signal Evidence
Learning speed Repeatedly productive in unfamiliar businesses and functions
Aspiration Chose assignments that built capability, not just title
Operating altitude Moved from "how does my function succeed?" to "how does the company create value across the customer journey?"
Multiplier Became an advocate and sponsor for developing the next leaders the same way

What happened. Results improved meaningfully; the program was one contributor among several. It supported the operating change behind them: leaders understood the enterprise, had wider networks, and aligned around the customer. The company then absorbed leadership transitions, rapid digitization, new competitors, and tighter regulation while holding its operating performance.

The proof. Years later, two senior leaders in a major region retired at the same time. He was named interim leader. The plan did not create him when the vacancy appeared. It revealed that the work to make him ready had already been done.

Lesson. The best proof of bench strength is not that someone was labeled ready. It is that when a critical leader leaves, someone steps into the work without the organization losing judgment, relationships, momentum, or customer trust.

Case 2: When the proven external leader did not transfer

Situation. A hypergrowth software company wanted to strengthen its enterprise business. The external candidate looked impossible to beat: a long, successful record at a large, mature enterprise company, leading a large sales organization with deep executive relationships. The logic was compelling: who better to teach a young company to sell to the largest enterprises?

The context that changed. His previous company was large, stable, and relationship-driven. His leadership model fit it: hire capable people, give them room, hold them to outcomes, do not over-manage experienced leaders. The new company was growing at extraordinary speed, reorganizing almost continuously, and ran a demanding management system of tight alignment and frequent inspection.

Both cultures valued empowerment. They differed in how it worked. In the mature company, autonomy lived inside stable structures. In the hypergrowth company, autonomy depended on tight alignment, shared operating mechanisms, fast feedback, and constant inspection. His instinct to give leaders room, a strength before, became a liability. Teams needed synchronization, not latitude.

What happened. The fit did not hold, and he moved on within two years to senior roles elsewhere. This was a mismatch of operating systems, not a judgment on the executive.

What the process missed. It had strong evidence that he had led a massive organization. It lacked evidence of transferability: what made him successful there, and would those behaviors produce the same results here?

Lesson. Past performance is evidence of capability in a context. When the plan calls for an outside hire, raise the evidence standard: comparable work, operating-context fit, adaptability, and multiplier fit. The most dangerous succession mistakes are not obviously bad candidates. They are outstanding candidates evaluated against the wrong evidence.

The pair

Built from inside Bought from outside
Sequence Develop breadth before the vacancy, observe adaptability across contexts, accumulate evidence of readiness, successor steps in Vacancy or strategic need, extraordinary résumé, transferability inferred from prior scale, mismatch found after appointment
Evidence of readiness Observed in this company's system over years Inferred from another company's system
Outcome Seamless interim leadership through a double retirement Moved on within two years

Succession asks who can do the next job. Bench strength proves it before you need them. A résumé only proves what someone did in the last system.

Supporting cases

The successor nobody planned a path for. A seller labeled unmotivated was found to be underchallenged. With the right mentor he finished well above quota for several years. He wanted to advance. No one named his next challenge, and he left for a competitor. Rule: flag top performers outgrowing their roles every quarter, and name the next challenge or accept that the market will.

The capable practitioner who was not a successor. An exceptional sales engineering leader had every ability the next stage needed except the wish to develop it. Rule: score aspiration separately from capability. A capable person who has not chosen the next stage is not a successor for it.

The sponsored internal candidate. Favored by a senior leader, he claimed never to have failed. The evaluator recommended against him and was overruled. The appointment did not last a year. Rule: run the sponsorship check in every talent review, and record any override with the risks to watch.